The Best 5 Weight Fly Reels Reviewed

Last Updated on June 21, 2021 by Donnell Henderson

The 5-weight fly reel is the most popular size for trout fishing. With this reel, any angler can cast numerous streamers, nymphs, and dry flies that vary in size. This size is also strong enough to battle huge trout. This reliable reel has made fishing on any freshwater lake fun and appealing even to newbies.

Therefore, if your primary game fish is trout and want a reel that you can use for catching other fish, then 5wt is the way to go.

Choosing the best 5-weight fly reel can be overwhelming, especially with the numerous options available. And that is because they vary in weight, price and have different drag systems. So I’ve created the following list of the best 5wt reels on the market to help you narrow your search.

So, let’s dive right in…

 

My Top Pick

My favorite is the Redington Behemoth, as it has the most powerful drag in its class. Despite its size, the Redington Behemoth is lighter than most reels in the market.

 

The Best 5 Weight Fly Reels Are

  1. Redington Behemoth — Best 5wt Fly Reel for the Money
  2. Anglerdream 5wt Fly Reel
  3. Galvan Rush Light Reels
  4. Piscifun Platte Fully Sealed Fly Fishing Reel
  5. Ross Evolution LTX Fly Reel
  6. Redington Zero Fly Reel
  7. Piscifun Sword Fly Reel

 

1. Redington Behemoth — Best 5wt Fly Reel for the Money

Redington Behemoth 5/6 Fly Reel - O.D Green

Redington has been manufacturing some of the best fishing gear in the market for years, and Behemoth is no exception. Redington designed this equipment for anglers who are looking to battle huge fishes. The main thing that makes this one stand out is its drag of 30 pounds, which is bigger than most in its class. Behemoth has the most powerful drag in its class with stunning aesthetics that pushes the limits of its design. Despite its size, it is lighter than a huge percentage of the reels in the market.

This fly reel is available in 5 colors; therefore, you can get one that matches your style. Behemoth is a great product for all fishing enthusiasts. While it might be a huge investment for beginners, it’s not as costly as most of the high-end reels in the market.

To provide you with reliable torque, Redington mixed steel friction plates with carbon fiber plates. Behemoth features a huge aluminum drag knob for better control when fishing. It also comes with twin molded handles with a soft-touch grip region that provides great feedback when battling huge fish. However, many users have complained that it’s not made of metal.

 

Specs

  • Brand: Redington
  • Material: carbon fiber
  • Maximum Drag: 30 lbs
  • Weight: 8 ounces

 

Pros

  • Behemoth has a deep spool
  • It comes with a huge drag control knob
  • Durable
  • It has the most powerful drag in its class
  • Available in 5 colors

 

Cons

  • It’s not made using metal

 

Overall Rating: 4.7 out of 5

Conclusion: Behemoth is a powerful and durable option for battling huge fish. And thanks to its unique design, it’s is perfect for both novice and experienced anglers.

CHECK CURRENT PRICE

2. Anglerdream 5wt Fly Reel

ANGLER DREAM AnglerDream 5 6WT Fly Reel with Line Combo Large Arbor Aluminum Fly Fishing Reels

The AnglerDream 5wt is a great reel for anglers who want to try 5wt fly fishing but do not want to spend a lot on a reel. Angler’s dream has produced several reels, but this is the best option in their 5wt lineup. This affordable option will allow you to catch trout and get them into your net easily. And that is because it has a smooth and reliable disc drag system. Its all-aluminum construction with huge arbor designs is designed to serve you a very long time.

This reel line has a high-tech PVC coating outside the braided line that guarantees durability. AnglerDream 5WT is available in two color options (fluo green and sky blue). It with a 50-yard long backing line and a 100-foot nylon fly line. However, many anglers have complained about its durability.

 

Specs

  • Brand: Angler Dream
  • Material: aluminum
  • Fly Line: 100 ft

 

Pros

  • Affordable
  • Smooth 
  • Great disc drag system
  • Ideal for beginners
  • Available in two color options

 

Cons

  • Many users have complained about its durability

 

Overall Rating: 4.1 out of 5

Conclusion: AnglerDream is an affordable option that is perfect for individuals who want to try 5wt fishing.

CHECK CURRENT PRICE

3. Galvan Rush Light Reels

Galvan Rush Light Reel (Burnt Orange, 5)

Given that the 5-weight reels are usually considered to be all-round fishing rigs, there is a huge competition in this category. And Galvan Rush light is ranked among the best 5wt reels in the market. Featuring a huge torque drag system, the Galvan Rush Light allows the line to feed out smoothly. The Galvan Rush features a microtune adjustment that guarantees that your drag will be where you set it to be the entire time.

Weighing about 5.2 ounces, the Galvan Rush is rugged enough to serve you for years, yet it’s light enough to allow you to fish. Galvan Rush Light is available in 5 different colors, so you can get a one that matches your style. Its open-backed, tri-spoke design provides a perfect combination of function and form.

Galvan Rush has a narrow spool with a retrieval rate of about 7.2 inches per turn, plus it can hold about 130yards of line. Galvan Rush has a small-sized handle while the drag knob is comfortable and easy to adjust. However, since its drag system is not closed, the Galvan Rush is not ideal for saltwater fishing.

 

Specs

  • Brand: Galvan fly reel
  • Weight: 5.15 ounces
  • Maximum Drag: 27 lbs
  • Retrieval Rate: 7.2 in per turn

 

Pros

  • Durable
  • it offers a very smooth drag system
  • The push-button is quite dependable and easy to use
  • The incoming click is great
  • It’s available in five colors

 

Cons

  • It’s not ideal for saltwater fishing since its drag system is not sealed

 

Overall Rating: 5 out of 5

Conclusion: Galvan Rush Light is a durable reel that can help you battle huge fish. However, since its drag system is not sealed, it’s not ideal for saltwater fishing.

CHECK CURRENT PRICE

4. Piscifun Platte Fully Sealed Fly Fishing Reel

Piscifun Platte Fully Sealed Drag Large Arbor Fly Fishing Reel with CNC-machined Aluminum Alloy Body 5/6 Black

For an entry-level option, Piscifun Platte is a great option that offers tremendous capabilities and value to anglers. Piscifun Platte is a fully CNC-machined reel that provides a high durability level that you might not get with die-cast reels. This reel’s spool and frame are made from 6061 T6 aluminum, which is strong and yet lighter. The huge arbor design helps you reel your line in quickly, thus giving you an edge over saltwater and freshwater fishes. Weighing about 0.39 pounds, this reel matches perfectly with most of the lightweight rods.

Piscifun Platte has a fully sealed carbon to steel drag system that seals out the grit and water, ensuring your reel serves you for a very long time. It also requires little to no maintenance except for rinsing after fishing in saltwater. It features a huge knob with a knurled edge that provides a perfect grip for quick adjustment. The spool has a quick-release button that comes in handy when you need to replace your line. However, some people have complained that it’s a tad heavy.

 

Specs

  • Brand: Piscifun
  • Material: Aluminum
  • Weight: 0.39 pounds
  • Drag System: Teflon/Cork disc

 

Pros

  • Lifetime warranty
  • Durable
  • Offers great performance
  • Fully sealed drag makes it ideal for saltwater fishing
  • Features a quick spool release
  • Available in several color options

 

Cons

  • It can be a tad heavy for some users

 

Overall Rating: 4.4 out of 5

Conclusion: Piscifun Platte has a sealed drag system; therefore, it’s ideal for saltwater fishing.

CHECK CURRENT PRICE

5. Ross Evolution LTX Fly Reel

Ross Reels Evolution LTX 5-6- Black

Evolution LTX is a perfect continuation of unique fly fishing lines from Ross Reels. Its unique design is loved by several anglers thanks to its robust durability and smooth feed. Ross Reels claims that the Evolution LTX is about four times stronger than its predecessor, Evolution LT. Evolution LTX features a unique system that gives it a maximum drag of about 7 pounds. That’s more than you will ever need for fly fishing.

Ross Reels maintained this line’s iconic smooth operation with the evolution LTX; however, they did change the handle. The LTX’s huge arbor spool has a unique handle that has been made from canvas phenolic rod. The new material helps increase grip, add durability while reducing the weight. Its unique handle makes it perfect for battling huge fish.

Evolution LTX is ideal for freshwater anglers who enjoy catching some saltwater fish like redfish, sea trout, and striped bass. Evolution LTX’s impressive drag system will never disappoint, especially when fighting huge trout. However, this reel’s line capacity is a tad low for saltwater fishing.

 

Specs

  • Brand: Ross Reels
  • Material: 6061-T6 aluminum
  • Weight: 8.8 oz
  • Drag System: stacked disc

 

Pros

  • Corrosion-resistant
  • Easy to clean
  • It has a superior drag system that can battle huge fishes
  • The machined-canvas phenolic handle provides the needed grip 

 

Cons

  • Its line capacity is not ideal for saltwater adventures

 

Overall Rating: 5.0 out of 5

Conclusion: thanks to its unique design, this reel is ideal for anglers who love saltwater and freshwater fishing.

CHECK CURRENT PRICE

6. Redington Zero Fly Reel

Redington Zero 4/5 Reel - Avocado (5-5507R45V)

Zero is another great one from Redington that was designed with the anglers’ needs in mind. Zero makes for perfect gear for beginners looking for a reliable reel on a budget of less than $100. But, don’t let its light weight and simplicity fool you; it can help you wrangle a wide range of fishes.

Zero is the lightest in its class. And that is the first aspect of this reel that you will notice. Because it’s lightweight, Zero can give you optimum performance with any rod. Plus, it easily converts to the right or left hand retrieve.

Zero comes with a huge arbor design that increases the line retrieval speed while reducing line memory. Plus, its spring-loaded clicker drag system brings a unique click sound to the battle as soon as you catch a fish. And for maximum grip, Zero has some soft-touch ergonomic handles. However, it comes with low drag power, so it’s not ideal for catching big game in huge rivers.

 

Specs

  • Brand: Redington
  • Material: plastic
  • Weight: 0.35 pounds
  • Diameter: 3.3 inches
  • Backing Capacity: 20pounds for about 100yards

 

Pros

  • It’s affordable
  • Its super lightweight
  • It has a durable construction
  • It comes in a wide range of colors
  • Its huge arbor reels in line quickly and reduces the line memory issue

 

Cons

  • It has very low drag power

 

Overall Rating: 4.6 out of 5

Conclusion: Not ideal for big game fishing.

CHECK CURRENT PRICE

7. Piscifun Sword Fly Reel

Piscifun Sword Fly Fishing Reel with CNC-machined Aluminum Alloy Body 5/6 Gunmetal

Piscifun Sword is another great product from Piscifun that comes with smooth drag capabilities. Piscifun Sword has a beautiful finish, plus it was made to resist corroding with time. Its mid-sized arbor has been made to reduce wear and tear on your line. Piscifun Sword has a durable and lightweight construction that is made from 6061-T6 aluminum alloy. Its huge CNC hollow design makes it lighter than most options on the market.

Piscifun Sword features a stainless steel drag system with a 1-way clutch bearing that provides a smooth experience. Piscifun Sword has excellent retrieval capabilities. The clutch on this moves in 1 direction; therefore, Piscifun will help you switch from left-side retrieval to the right side. However, some anglers have complained that it doesn’t have a lot of space for the line. 

Specs

  • Brand: Piscifun
  • Material: aluminum and stainless steel
  • Weight: 4.7 oz

 

Pros

  • Durable
  • Lightweight
  • It has an anodized finish
  • Affordable
  • It comes with a 3-year warranty from the manufacturer

 

Cons

  • It doesn’t have a lot of space for the fishing line

 

Overall Rating: 4.6 out of 5

Conclusion: Piscifun Sword is an affordable fishing reel that can serve you for a very long time. Plus it has a three-year warranty from the manufacturer.

CHECK CURRENT PRICE

best 5 weight fly reel

 

How to Choose the Right 5-Weight Reel

Most anglers tend to undermine the importance of a fly reel. You will hear some of them saying things like “generally the reel just holds the line.” which is true sometimes. However, all these changes when they are chasing their trophy fish. Therefore, it’s always good to have a reliable reel in your arsenal.

Plus, you don’t need to spend a lot to get a reliable fishing reel. However, choosing the right 5wt reel for you can be quite tricky, especially with the numerous options available. So here are some of the key factors to consider when buying a 5wt fishing reel.

 

Drag System

The most common found on 5wt fishing reels are disc drag and click and pawl. The disc drag is way stronger than the click and pawl system; therefore, disc drag 5wt reels are more expensive.

However, if you plan on fishing in places with huge fish, you need a disc drag, which can handle any battle with a massive fish.

 

The Weight

Weight matters a lot, especially if you plan on fishing for an extended period. Remember casting rods with heavy reels can result in fatigue, which will mess up your holiday. Therefore, make sure you pay attention to its weight and how it balances with your rod. After all, you are better off with a somewhat heavy reel that balances perfectly with your rod.

 

Material

The material used to make a reel plays a key role in its durability and price. So if you plan on using your reel for fishing huge fishes, make sure you get a durable reel.

The best 5wt fishing reels in the market are made using either machined or milled aluminum. Aluminum reels are durable and strong and can serve a hardcore angler for a number of seasons without breaking down.

 

The Start-up Inertia

Have you ever noticed that your drag system seems sticky when it starts to release the fishing line? Well, that sticky feeling is the friction caused by start-up inertia. But as soon as the friction lets go, you might feel like your reel doesn’t have a drag system at all.

High-quality reels feature some components that reduce friction and give you a consistent and smooth experience.

 

Final Thoughts

The quality of your gear usually determines the success of every fishing trip. And one of the main things that can mess up your trip is purchasing the wrong 5wt reel. A wrong reel that doesn’t balance with your rod can make fishing almost impossible for you.

Therefore, make sure you choose the right reel that matches your fishing style and can battle massive fishes. You want something durable, lightweight, and have a reliable drag system. So we have created the above list of the best 5-weight fly reels in the market for you to choose from.

And if we were to pick from our list, we would choose the Redington Behemoth. And that is because it is a durable gear that is designed to battle huge fishes. Redington Behemoth fly reel has a very powerful drag that can guarantee you success every time you catch a fish.

Scroll to Top